As Alice‘s story unfolds, you may have noticed she has been struggling to remember a lot of things. She seems to have forgotten a bit more than we intended! Speaking to Alice while wearing Annie’s Beach Outfit and Red Hat before starting Annie’s Lost Hat quest causes Alice not to recognize her properly the first time.
In order to get her back on track, we recommend saving and quitting while wearing the outfit, then talking to her again!
If she's still not quite recognizing the outfit after that, please double check that you've properly selected all three elements of the outfit that she wants to see.